Tuesday, July 25, 2006

Scopus Mini Review

As some of you may already know, David Rothman previously posted on Michael Stephen’s Tame the Web that Elsevier was behind on RSS developments and Damien Sherman of Elsevier’s Scopus took exception because Scopus does offer RSS feeds on its searches. Rothman asked Sherman for temporary access to Scopus so that he could kick the tires and explore its RSS feature.

After poking around and trying things out. Rothman provides a "very brief review" of Scopus on his blog, complete with pictures.

Below is Rothman's summary, for the his full review, go to Scopus RSS: a very brief review.

Things I (Rothman) like about Scopus RSS:

  • The RSS feature is well-integrated in the search results page, and easy
    to find.
  • Naming of feeds makes them clear and unambiguous when they appear
    in the aggregator.
  • The RSS URL is created quickly and easily.

Things I’d (Rothman) like to see Scopus RSS do next:

  • The RSS items should contain, if not the full abstract, at least a few lines of it. Now, all that shows up in the aggregator is the hyperlinked title and a one-line description of the source. More detail in the item would allow the user to do some filtering without having to go to Scopus. This would save the user’s time (Ranganathan's 4th law, anyone?). RSS feed URL produced should be a live hyperlink, not just text. This lets users with many kinds of subscription tools subscribe more easily.
  • The RSS feed contains ONLY the Scopus results, not the web results. Ideally, the user should have the option of whether to do one of the two, or both.
  • More user documentation about how Scopus RSS feeds will
    work is needed. It isn’t clear, for instance, how often
    the search that generates the feed will be executed. Perhaps the user could
    select from a menu how often he/she would like the search to be executed and new
    results generated for the feed.
  • Change the RSS button to the proposed standard.

Summary: Scopus is off to a good start with their offering search results as RSS feeds and should be applauded for having them. However, from the perspective of someone working towards SDI goals, its RSS features are not yet caught up to PubMed in usefulness.

Thanks David for the brief insight into Scopus and RSS. I think it is helpful.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home

RSS Button Subscribe to this feed.
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 License.
       
 
The Krafty Librarian has been a medical librarian since 1998. She is currently the medical librarian for a hospital system in Ohio. You can email her at: